Bitter taste to confectionary disputes

KitKat Nestlé - confectionary disputes

 

Last week the UK Court of Appeal ruled on the long running battle between Nestlé and Cadbury (owned by Mondeleze) over the attempt to register the shape of the KitKat bar in the UK.  Trademarks need to be a “badge of origin”. In particular registration of a shape mark requires good evidence of acquired distinctiveness to show that consumers rely on shape in a “trade mark sense”. The UK court has ruled that this is not the case for the KitKat shape. The mere fact that consumers recognise the mark is insufficient and the applicant must demonstrate that a significant proportion of the relevant public rely on the mark to indicate the product origin.

KitKat Bar - shape mark

Once again this shows how applications for non-traditional marks are more vulnerable to objections for lack of distinctive character.

But it is also interesting that the industry continues to fight these costly battles. Most of us might view these disputes as irrelevant and a waste of money but the parties involved see them as a battle for an all-important edge in the marketplace. The confectionery industry is extremely competitive – the aim is to ring-fence your brand and intellectual property rights in order to block others from cutting into your space.

There are quite a few registered shape marks in the world of confectionery and many of them have seen some level of trademark dispute.

 

Some well-known shape marks:

Bitter taste to confectionary disputes

The maker of the Golden Bunny, Lindt, launched a chocolate teddy bear. Haribo, which invented gummy bears in the 1920s, said shoppers would confuse the two products, even though Lindt’s bears are made of chocolate and gummy bears are jelly sweets.

 

Examples of colour marks:

Color marks

Both these shades of purple are used for chocolate products and are owned by Kraft / Mondelez. But there has been an ongoing battle between Nestle and Cadbury about the legitimacy of use as a trademark. The British public has linked this shade of purple with Cadbury for over a century in the same way that the Milka shade is well accepted by a wider European consumer audience.

Cyber-blurring: the strategy used by Macron’s digital team to face cyberattacks

Cyber-blurring - the strategy used by Macron’s digital team
Photo : www.gouvernement.fr

 

May the 5th , 2017, two hours before the end of 2017 presidential campaign, thousands of documents owned by the campaign team of the candidate Emmanuel Macron have been leaked and have been made public on American forum 4Chan, relayed by Wikileaks. Social media have played an important role in the attack and content diffusion: internal discussion of the political party, briefing notes, pictures, bills, accounting, which represent 9 gigaoctets of hacked data.

Since the beginning of the presidential campaign, it wasn’t the first attack faced by the team of En Marche’s candidate.  Alerted of a potential attack a long time ago, they have set up a cyber-blurring strategy to defend themselves. This method creates dozens of false documents (false emails, false passwords, false accounts) trying to slow down hackers’ work. This strategy is often used in the banking field to protect their customers. (This diversion method is also called digital blurring.)

 

L'Express Twitter account - Cyber-blurring: the strategy used by Macron’s digital team to face cyberattacks
L’Express Twitter account

 

Even if Mounir Mahjoubi, digital director of the En Marche campaign, thinks to have slowed down the hackers’ job with this cyber-blurring method, despite these measures, the attack was not avoided.

The hackers didn’t ask for money in exchange of the documents publishing. These documents which are not compromising for the Emmanuel Macron’s team, were not monetizable because the hackers would have to sort out 9 gigaoctets of data in a few period of time.

Consequences are few on the presidential campaign and the En Marche staff was not really affected. This counterattack was well implemented.

The hackers who were against Macron, didn’t have the success desired. Nevertheless, this failure will get them to become smarter, more ingenious, less visible and better prepared for a next attack.

To be continued.

Mastodon : What about cybersquatting ?

Mastodon : What about cybersquatting

 

Communication on social media is the subject of many justified concerns from trademarks owners. As a matter of fact, user’s names creation, called “username”, are not legally protected beforehand. Specifically, the owner has to register or retrieve the username corresponding to their brand or demonstrate to the social media that the use of their brand is used with ill intent. In short, it’s a time consuming activity…

Mastodon, a few months old social network, trendy since a few days, is the subject of some articles regarding its nature, process and goal. But what about the associated brands protection?

Mastodon is a social network, created by Eugen Rochko, a 24 years old German developer. Twitter’s clone where characters are limited to 500, Mastodon is free, open source and not centralized. We will be interested in this last term. It’s possible to access Mastodon with its “basic official” website mastodon.social.

However mastodon.social is only an instance, you can use others like mastodon.fun developed in Angers. You choose a username for an instance and your complete username will be @username@instance. Keep in mind that instances are associable with each other, giving them a federal term.

Anyone can create an instance, so you have two cumulative possibilities:

  • Either you register your brand for all existing instances (today there are more than 2000 of them and it’s only the beginning).
  • Or you create your instance, closed, corresponding to your brand.

As you might have guessed, I will advise you the second choice: as it doesn’t exist any certification on Mastodon, anyone can be anybody. But by creating an instance corresponding to your principal domain name, you create this certification!

Of course .BRAND owners should create social.BRAND so they have a dedicated instance which allows them to highlight their TLD, like @pierre.dupont@social.brand.

If you need more information on Mastodon, don’t hesitate to contact us.

Good name, bad product

New product development is exciting – and costly. In addition to the essential R&D, market research and marketing initiatives, all products require a name which is (ideally) distinctive and available. Finding the right name in itself is a costly business that involves many steps: name & logo creation, trademark research, brand validation & strategy, trademark filing and protection). Depending on where you plan to launch and therefore protect your product name will define the costs which will probably range from $5,000 to $50,000+.

A failed product is a costly error for any company. In addition to the wasted time the failure can haunt companies for years to come. Now a new museum is opening in Sweden to celebrate these failures and hopefully to help companies learn how to succeed.

The Museum of Failure (museumoffailure.se) opens in Helsingborg in June this year with the tag line “Learning is the only way to turn failure into success”. The collection consists of over sixty failed products and services from around the world, many of which have carefully created trademarked names. The founder Samuel West comments that even big and competent companies fail. It is important to create a culture that accepts failure and learns from it.

Here are some of the branded exhibits which have failed for various reasons ranging from poor design to products that were just plain awful or simply useless.

 

Examples of failed products

 

One interesting exhibit on display is a board game called Trump, The Game. This was similar to Monopoly but with Trump dollars, Trump properties and T-shaped game pieces. Trump, The Game was launched in 1989 but only sold 800,000 units instead of the estimated two million copies. It was re-released in 2004 but still failed to impress. It is interesting to note that the original trade mark is no longer in force but a new application was filed in the US at the end 2016.

 

Trump, The Game

New extensions: The first signs of a (R)evolution?

Domain names registration strategies follow reasoning sometimes hard to understand. However “sheep-like” reasoning is the one we can easily observe.

When Alphabet (Google) used for the first time its domain name ABC.XYZ, a sensitive rise of registrations for this extension has been observed. More than a simple registration, ABC.XYZ has created for the public, informed or not, an interrogation on the extension used: “they aren’t in .COM?”

 

New extension - abc.xyz Alphabet Google

 

New gTLDs’s program by ICANN has generated many thoughts on naming politic on the web. Until now, these extensions weren’t well known by the general public, despite the real concern of the brands to communicate on this subject: BNP Paribas, Leclerc and AXA for French examples, which have chosen a dedicated extension.

New gTLDs creation allows to register domain name by searching to give a meaning to the associated activity: be it geographical or by sector.

That way, the following sentence makes more sense: “When I look at the domain name, I know what’s behind it”.

Today, despite this opportunity, few companies of big scale have chosen to use a new extension. And none to my knowledge, suppress its former address to go on the new one. Which can be quite logical. But things which seem unchanging, are changing.

DXC an American company, present in NYSE, has changed its short domain name, three characters, dxc.com to dxc.technology. It was our colleagues of DNW who announced this news. However the email addresses service didn’t move to the new extension yet.

 

New extension - dxc.technology
Example of dxc.technology

 

This information may seem of little importance, but have in mind the impact it will have on the process of new extensions use. Simply put, it begins with the importance and the safety of the extension for a company to change. Wait for the next step! It may only be the beginning of an underlying trend on communication and naming strategy on Internet.

Technology revolution growth is usually slower than the one planned, but its impact is often more important… To be continued.