Interview with our DMARC Consultant, Sébastien Fischer, with the CSA

A healthy mail environment doesn’t just happen on its own. It takes companies and people who are actively committed to keeping email an open, secure, and trustworthy communication channel. The Certified Senders Alliance (CSA) recognizes this commitment with its “Supporter Spotlight” series, and we are delighted to be part of it.

The Certified Senders Alliance (CSA) has been the European certification body for email senders since 2004 and, as a joint initiative of eco and DDV, acts as an intermediary between email service providers and senders. As a sponsor, together with our partner Merox, we’re contributing our DMARC expertise to the fight against phishing and identity theft.

We’re continuing this commitment beyond our sponsorship partnership: In December, we’re hosting a webinar on the topic of phishing.

Our conversation with the CSA shows just how important this topic is in practice: Sébastien Fischer, a DMARC consultant at Nameshield who has been an expert in email deliverability for 18 years, talks about his early days at Emailvision all the way to his current work with us in the field of domain security.

Here is the full interview.

CSA: What still fascinates you about email today?

To start off, let’s take a look back at his career: We wanted to know what has fascinated him about this field over the years.

SF: I took my first steps in email marketing—and specifically in the field of email deliverability—18 years ago at Emailvision. There, I discovered an incredible communication channel that is constantly evolving, which is what makes it so fascinating on so many levels:

  • Changes in marketing practices: Mass emails—which are still sent by some advertisers—have given way to more targeted emails with personalized content.
  • Changes in spam techniques: Spammers can be very skilled marketers and quickly adapt to new technologies to bypass anti-spam filters and deceive end users.
  • Advances in filtering techniques: Anti-spam filters use complex reputation systems based on various indicators, including technical configuration, authentication, historical reputation data for domains and IP addresses, content analysis, detection of suspicious behavior, and analysis of users’ email behavior.
  • Evolving standards: Over the past 20 years, numerous RFCs have been published, and some have evolved or will continue to evolve—I’m thinking in particular of DMARC and version 2 of DKIM.
  • Legal developments: The introduction of the GDPR a few years ago changed the rules of the game. All advertisers must adapt quickly to these changes if they want to continue reaching their users’ inboxes.

CSA: What is the challenge that Nameshield is particularly committed to addressing?

A key challenge for Nameshield is protecting brands from domain spoofing and phishing—through the targeted use of authentication protocols such as SPF, DKIM, and DMARC to secure companies’ digital identities.

SF: Nameshield is a global leader in domain management. It is important to us to be a one-stop shop for our customers when it comes to deploying state-of-the-art technologies to secure incoming and outgoing email traffic, while also serving as an advocate for these technologies to ensure a smooth transition for all our customers—so that this important communication channel remains as secure and reliable as possible.

CSA: What does it take to ensure that email remains a reliable channel?

SF: Email is a fantastic communication channel, but there are certain areas where it could still be significantly improved:

  • Greater security: The adoption of DMARC with a restrictive security policy remains too low—a godsend for any attacker who likes to use unprotected domains for their phishing emails.
  • More BIMI: The use of a VMC brand certificate with BIMI—to display the logo and a distinctive checkmark in the inboxes of certain providers—increases a brand’s visibility, much to the delight of marketing teams. It also lends greater legitimacy to emails sent to recipients’ inboxes, thereby helping to prevent confusion.
  • Greater cyber awareness among businesses and individuals: Recognizing phishing emails and helping to protect passwords to prevent account and data theft.

More members of the CSA (Certified Senders Alliance) and its certification program: To deliver the right message to the right person in their inbox at the right time.

CSA: Why is the CSA’s collaboration with Nameshield important to you?

SF: The CSA is a key European organization in the field of email deliverability and trust, particularly thanks to its email certification program. The CSA is not only a trusted third party for numerous local and international providers but also serves as a legal and technological authority—which gives it strong legitimacy and considerable prestige within the industry. The organization offers invaluable support to anyone looking to improve the quality of their email marketing—which is precisely why we are committed to supporting it.


Our conversation with Sébastien Fischer demonstrates once again that a secure and trustworthy email ecosystem is a collective effort. At Nameshield, we work every day—together with partners like the CSA—to further advance domain security and email deliverability.


Many thanks to the CSA for the insightful questions and the great collaboration!


Learn more about DMARC or contact us here.

Nameshield’s DNS Premium labelled France Cybersecurity

The digital transformation of companies creates an increasing dependence on networks.

Websites, emails, VPN, applications… these company key services must remain accessible. An interruption would be dramatic.

DNS is the access point to all these services. It translates domain names into IP addresses and routes traffic to these services. It is increasingly exposed to attacks, yet remains poorly secured due to a lack of knowledge. With the increase in threats, maintaining its DNS infrastructure is becoming more and more complex.

Securing strategic domain names by hosting them on highly secure DNS offering permanent availability, to avoid any interruption to company key services, has become a necessity.

Nameshield, certified ISO 27001 on all its registrar activities, protects companies’ critical digital services against cyber threats, and proposes a DNS Premium solution that ensures high availability of online services.

Nameshield’s DNS Premium has been labelled France Cybersecurity since 2018. This label is a guarantee for users that Nameshield’s products and services present a level of quality in cybersecurity verified by an independent jury.

“Cybersecurity is at the heart of Nameshield’s DNA, through its CERT and ISO 27001 certification. In a sector dominated by American players, this label is the perfect way to highlight our sovereign solutions such as DNS Premium“, Christophe Gérard, Nameshield’s Products Director.

Nameshield signs up the Paris Call in order to actively contribute to the Internet’s stability

Paris Call - Nameshield

Just one year ago, in the context of the first Paris Peace Forum, the French President, Emmanuel Macron, launched the Paris Call for trust and security in cyberspace. This call is a political declaration aiming to express a mobilization on the stability in the cyberspace and strengthens the efforts of the international community and many actors involved in the digital security issues. This text reminds some principles that we think are fundamental, like the application of the international rights and the Human rights in the cyberspace. It also highlights the need of a multi actors’ approach, to create standards which will allow us to fully benefit, i.e. in a reliable and secure way, from opportunities provided by the digital revolution.

Lastly, the Paris Call promotes the strengthening of the digital products and services’ security that we use for example, in our daily lives. The text aims in that sense, to prevent cyberattacks perpetrated by malicious actors, which threaten all the users of the cyberspace.

Aware that our Society’s development, on the economic, cultural and democratic fronts, requires a strengthened trust of the information that flows through the Internet, Nameshield, which has worked for 25 years to protect the digital identity of its clients; companies, local collectivities and administrations through the use of their domain names, wished to join this initiative and sign the Paris Call.

Its job consists in ensuring the integrity and resilience of the identity of individuals and organizations on the Internet, represented today by the domain name. By highly protecting data on domain name identity cards (Whois) and by providing a high availability and high performance service through the associated Domain Name System (DNS), Nameshield contributes to a large extent to the second principle of the Paris Call: Protecting the Internet. To prevent activity that intentionally and substantially damages the general availability or integrity of the public core of the Internet.

Cornerstone of the Web, the Domain Name System (DNS) serves as the Internet directory. This protocol translates a domain name into an IP address, based on a database distributed on thousands of machines. If the DNS falls because of data corruption or a denial of service attack, all your websites and emails would become inaccessible, which is completely unthinkable nowadays! The DNS must be protected and must stay highly available.

Protocol created in the 1980’s, security flaws regarding the usual functioning of the DNS have been identified since its creation. That is why, a new secured protocol, DNSSEC, has thus been developed to ensure the authenticity of the exchanges through a certified signature. Other solutions can complete the resilience of your identity on the Internet: the registry lock, SSL certificates…

The security solutions proposed by Nameshield, an independent French company that stores its data in France and possesses its own anycast and resilient DNS infrastructure, certified ISO 27001 on all its domain names activity, are compliant with the ANSSI recommendations on the good practices regarding the domain names’ acquisition and exploitation.

In the context of the 2nd Paris Peace Forum, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs wished to illustrate the second principle of the Paris Call: Protect the Internet by highlighting the services proposed by Nameshield. The company is proud to be able to collaborate, at its level, with the actors implicated in digital security issues in order to make the Internet more reliable and thus contribute to the security of the cyberspace.

https://pariscall.international/en/principles

What has become of the big dreams of the big .BRANDs ?

7713692070_47a12d10a0_h

In 2012, ICANN received 643 applications for restricted use generic Top Level Domains extensions by brand owners. Recently, a surprising proportion of these, so called, .BRAND applications have been withdrawn, often resulting in the loss of the entire application fee ($185,000).

Why have these brand owners taken the decision to relinquish control over their very own piece of the Internet infrastructure? Is this a tactical response to a strategic direction or are they simply lacking the ideas and domain name registry experience to make the most of this investment? Jean-Francois Vanden Eynde, head of registry services at Nameshield investigates.

It is important to acclimatise the internet public to the use of the new .BRAND extensions since little has been done by ICANN to promote the overall new gTLD concept

The new generic Top Level Domain (gTLD) program has been a long time coming. And, from late 2013 onwards, new domain extensions have been live on the Internet, going largely unnoticed by the general public. At the time of writing, 548 new domain extensions have been delegated (the domain extension resolves in the root zone of the internet and is therefore live), only 96 of these are .BRAND applications, but these already include some well-known brands such as .cartier, .marriott, .nissan, .bnpparisbas and .bbc.

Note: When a domain extension is delegated it must immediately host a website on nic.extension (e.g. try typing nic.cartier or nic.marriott into the address bar of a web-browser).

Of the 643 .BRAND applications 56 have already been withdrawn by brand owners including some household names such as Amazon, General Motors (.chevy), Bloomingdales, Hasbro International Inc. (.transformers) and ProMark Brands Inc. (.Heinz and .Ketchup). It is expected that a greater number of .BRAND applicants will withdraw before the program reaches its conclusion, but what reasons do Brand owners have for turning their backs on an investment that runs into hundreds of thousands of dollars?

While, in the application phase, there was no shortage of experts offering to write a new gTLD application on behalf of a brand owner, those same experts seem to disappear when it comes to the implementation phase.

1. Competitive advantage mitigation

It was a well known fact, that often went unmentioned, that some brand owners applied for New gTLDs simply to ensure that their competition did not have a clear run at the domain extension and thereby gain competitive advantage.

If the completion does not apply and, despite being the applicant, you do not want to use the domain extension yourself, then an early withdrawal will reduce your losses and ensure that none of your competitors get to use the domain extension unless they apply for it in a future round. This type of strategy has been used by a number of brand owners in particular for generic terms.

2. Prevailing objections

During the application process, there was a period where those who had a grievance against an application could file an objection on one of four grounds. If the objector prevailed against the applicant then the application would have to be withdrawn.

For example, Ralph Lauren was forced to withdraw its application for .polo after an objection from the United States Polo Association, Inc. despite having well established trademarks for the term.

There are, in fact, very few people in the world who actually have the experience to implement and run a gTLD registry. This lack of know-how can make some companies revisit their original ‘green light’ decision.

They say that the only constant is change and its safe to say that nowadays corporations change their strategic direction and their personnel with alarming rapidity.

If key supporters of a company’s new gTLD program leave the business then it can quickly lead to the failure of a .BRAND particularly if this happens at the very top.

4. Lack of experience

One of the things that has become clear as the new gTLD program has unfolded is that, while in the application phase there was no shortage of experts offering to write a new gTLD application on behalf of a brand owner, those same experts seem to disappear when it comes to the implementation phase.

There are, in fact, very few people in the world who actually have the experience of implementing and running a gTLD registry. This lack of know-how can make some companies revisit their original decision.

5. Lack of need

Many .BRAND gTLDs will have been applied for defensive reasons without the brand owner considering the use to which a .BRAND new gTLD might be put. Since a new gTLD is really an intangible asset that involves a considerable on-going investment to maintain, it is understandable that some companies may reconsider the need for their own .BRAND gTLD.

6. Lack of ideas

For those of us that have worked in the domain name industry for a while, the idea of owning a piece of internet infrastructure to do with what you will has a considerable attraction. That is because Internet infrastructure is our business. For most brand owners, it is not. While there are few enough people on the planet that understand how to implement and run a gTLD registry, there are even fewer who know how to align a registry to support the needs of a single brand. Similarly, those who understand the needs of the brand usually do not fully understand how a .BRAND gTLD can help them realise corporate strategy.

What is noticeable by its absence is that to date very few of the .BRAND gTLDs, that have been delegated, are actually being used in anger in marketing messages, email or in fact online. The thing that will change this industry and bring us out of the .com era and into the “age of .anything” is for .BRAND tlds to actually start using their unique internet assets. Imagine what will happen when Nike starts using its .NIKE gTLD in television advertising or McDonalds starts putting its .MCD web-addresses on all of its collateral.

Before unleashing a new gTLD, brand owners must make sure that existing marketing campaigns, message infrastructure and website traffic and, above all, revenues are not adversely affected.

 

Less .haste more .speed

Unlike open registries, whose domain names are available to anyone, a .BRAND registry is under much less commercial pressure to launch. This is one of the principal reasons that the world is yet to see much movement in the .BRAND gTLD space. Another potential reason is that many .BRAND owners seem to view delegation as the end of something rather than the beginning of a new internet era for them.

Before unleashing a new gTLD, brand owners must make sure that existing marketing campaigns, message infrastructure and website traffic and, above all, revenues are not adversely affected. For a multinational brand there is a whole host of internal matters to address, including internal education programs, marketing style guides, email addresses and footers and effect on corporate culture.

Some brand owners may consider that this considerable upheaval is not worth the effort at this stage and may continue to use and promote their existing domain name infrastructure for some time to come.

However, brand owners should not dismiss, through lack of understanding, the long-term benefits that a new gTLD infrastructure can bring to their business. Certainly, careful consideration should be given to maximising the use, to which their new online intellectual property asset can be put.

 

It’s better to .Use it! don’t .Lose it!

What might brand owners do with their gTLD as soon as it’s delegated? There are a number of options that brand owners can choose to implement with their new domain extension such as:

1. Park it

Applicants who applied for defensive reasons will typically park their domain extension and register very few domains. This can be likened to purchasing an expensive Ferrari and leaving it in the garage. While this is a valid and understandable option, given the lack of available expertise within brand owners of operating Internet infrastructure, it does nothing to capitalise on a potential competitive advantage against competitors that have not applied for a new gTLD. For example, Nike successfully applied for .Nike whereas Adidas and Reebok chose not to apply. Nike now has a window of opportunity to exploit this competitive advantage.

2. Point it.

The very least a band owner should do is use this new and comparatively low cost Internet naming infrastructure to maximise traffic to its existing websites. Creating keyword domain names and forwarding the corresponding traffic to the brand owner’s main website costs little and may generate increased business and will certainly assist in search engine rankings.

3. Promote it

Some brand owners are already building their online corporate marketing strategy, if not their sales strategy, around their new .BRAND extension. They are using it to deliver important marketing messages about their values, culture and ethics to help reinforce the credibility of their brands. These informational pages can be placed on, what in .com terms would have been, premium domain names .

For example, Nike might host a website showing its strategy for environmental sustainability on sustainability.nike or ethically sourced products on fairtrade.nike or its focus on innovation and development on innovation.nike. If a brand owner wanted to do the same thing on the equivalent .com domain name they could be paying millions of dollars just for the domain name alone, if it was for sale at all. Using the equivalent .BRAND domain name should rank the site highly with the search engines and cost less than $5.

While no dates are set in stone for the opening of the next instalment of new gTLDs, brand owners and .BRAND owners alike should start preparing now.

It is important to acclimatise the internet public to the use of the new .BRAND extensions since little has been done to promote the overall new gTLD concept to the public. We saw elements of this recently at the Football world cup with McDonalds promoting www.mcd.com, which is only one step away from its .MCD extension.

Once the base elements of a new gTLD online strategy are in place, .BRAND owners should start focusing their Search Engine Optimisation (SEO) efforts and part of their Pay Per Click (PPC) budgets to their new domain extension. However, it is important to note that, while PPC can achieve rapid results it can consume large budgets and it is important that efforts to promote any new .BRAND extension should not get impede or add confusion to any existing online campaigns. SEO campaigns generally show gradual improvements over the space of 6 – 12 months, so it is important to start these campaigns as soon as possible.

While no dates are set in stone for the opening of the next instalment of new gTLDs, brand owners and .BRAND owners alike should start preparing now.

Those .BRAND owners who already have their gTLD delegated should not sit idle and let their competitive advantage disappear.

Brand owners who are considering applying in the next application round should start their planning now to ensure that when they finally get their gTLDs delegated they are ready to implement their marketing plans. And, brand owners who have no intention of applying for a new gTLD should still take stock because without a doubt this brand new namespace will affect their naming strategies, their domain name portfolios and their marketing messages.

Note: the original article, published in IPPRO magazine can be found here

Jean_Francois_Vanden_Eynde

Jean-Francois Vanden Eynde

Head of registry services

nms_logo_rvb_registry.fw